Collecting or Clashing : Why Collectors Are Facing More Backlash Than Ever

For decades, collectors have been seen as a bit different. Whether it was comic book, manga and video games enthusiasts lining up hours for new issues or action figure lovers hunting for rare finds, collecting was often viewed as a niche hobby, outside of the mainstream. But while collectors may have once been dismissed as socially awkward or overly obsessed with their interests, the perception has taken a darker turn.

Today, it’s not just mild teasing or the classic nerd stereotype : there’s an increasing wave of outright hostility toward collectors. Social media is filled with rude comments like “Why are you collecting toys at your grown age ?”, “Get a job” or “What’s the point of collecting all that plastic trash ?”. Instead of being seen as passionate enthusiasts, many collectors are now portrayed as wasteful, childish or even socially undesirable.

Minimalism As The New Go-to 

One major factor is the rise of minimalism and sustainability as social values. In the era of clean girl aesthetic, beige domination and where people are influenced to get rid of unnecessary items and reject overconsumption, collecting stands in direct contrast to these ideals. While minimalism promotes the idea that fewer things lead to a clearer mind, collecting is often about accumulation, preservation and in many cases, nostalgia.

Of course, minimalism and collecting aren’t inherently opposed. Many collectors are geniune about what they acquire, and some focus on rare and exclusive items rather than sheer quantity. But to outsiders, collectors are increasingly viewed as wasteful consumers whose only purpose is to amass tons of "useless” items. The nuance between mindful collecting and excessive consumerism is often lost in the broader conversation, leading to sweeping generalisations about the hobby. Outsiders also tend to judge collections based solely on their appearance, overlooking the fact that it took collectors years, sometimes decades, to build those.

A "Hierarchy" Within the World of Collectibles

It’s also important to note that not all collections are treated equally. Some collecting habits (like collecting rare vinyl records, high-end art figures or designer bags) are often seen as prestigious, even admirable. But when it comes to collectibles associated with geek culture, the attitude shifts totally.

Take Funko Pop figures, for example. Their affordability, accessibility, and mass-produced nature make them easy to collect (especially for new or younger collectors) yet they’re often mocked as a “lazy” form of collecting, lacking the depth or dedication associated with more traditional collectibles. Many hardcore collectors also look down on Funko Pop as “entry-level” or “casual” collecting, while outsiders mock the sheer volume of Funko Pop that some enthusiasts accumulate. The irony is that gatekeeping within collecting communities can sometimes be just as harsh as the judgment from outside them.

Similarly, fans who collect retro gaming consoles, rare action figures or first-edition books may still be considered nerdy but are generally met with more respect than those amassing shelves of contemporary, mass-market items. The distinction seems to come down to exclusivity and craftsmanship. If an item is rare, expensive or historically significant, it’s a “real” collectible. If it’s mainstream and accessible, it’s seen as pointless. 

Social Media and the Changing Perception of Collectors

The internet has played a double-edged role in the evolution of collecting communities. On one hand, it has connected enthusiasts, making it easier than ever to find rare items, join collector communities and share passion projects. On the other hand, it has exposed collectors to a much wider (and often much harsher) audience.

Whereas collectors once engaged primarily in niche forums, dedicated stores or conventions, their collections are now showcased on platforms like TikTok, Instagram and X (formerly Twitter). While this has led to some positive engagement, it has also made them easy targets for jokes. Viral posts often mock collectors, framing them as out-of-touch adults who spend too much money on "plastic trash" rather than "meaningful" projects.

The way collecting is presented on social media also plays into this shift. High-profile influencers show off massive, extravagant collections, sometimes giving the impression that collecting is purely about excess rather than appreciation. This spectacle fuels criticism, reinforcing the idea that collecting is nothing more than mindless consumerism.

The Future of Collecting: Reclaiming the Narrative

Despite the backlash, collecting isn’t disappearing anytime soon. In fact, it continues to thrive, with collectors finding new ways to share their passion while adapting to current cultural shifts. The rise of second-hand and vintage collecting aligns with sustainability values, offering a counterpoint to the argument that all collectors contribute to overconsumption. Similarly, many collectors are actively challenging stereotypes, emphasising the cultural and personal meaning of their collections.

The truth is : collecting, whether it’s comics, sneakers, action figures, movies props, vinyl records etc., has always been about more than just “accumulating things.” It’s about preserving popular culture, celebrating nostalgia, feeling genuine happiness and personal wellness. While mainstream perceptions may shift, the passion behind collecting remains unchanged. And at the end of the day, does it really matter if some people don’t understand it ? After all, collecting has never been about fitting in. It’s about dedicating yourself to what you love with intensity and passion.

The hostility toward collectors reflects broader cultural conversations about consumerism. But while trends come and go, the dedication of collectors has always been constant. Whether it’s vintage Star Wars figures, rare Marvel comics or carefully curated manga bookshelves, collectors will continue to find joy in their collections, regardless of whether the internet approves.

by. CYB3R GREEN